edited by
31,458 views
103 votes
103 votes

A program takes as input a balanced binary search tree with $n$ leaf nodes and computes the value of a function $g(x)$ for each node $x$. If the cost of computing $g(x)$ is: $$\Large \min \left ( \substack{\text{number of leaf-nodes}\\\text{in left-subtree of $x$}}\;,\; \substack{\text{number of leaf-nodes}\\\text{in right-subtree of $x$}}\right )$$

Then the worst-case time complexity of the program is?

  1. $\Theta (n)$
  2. $\Theta (n \log n)$
  3. $\Theta(n^2)$
  4. $\Theta (n^2\log n)$
edited by

11 Answers

Best answer
112 votes
112 votes

B. At the root node (first level) the cost would be $\Theta\left(\frac{n}{2}\right)$ as the tree is balanced.

At next level, we have 2 nodes and for each of them cost of computing $g(x)$ will be $\Theta\left(\frac{n}{4}\right)$. So, total cost at second level $= \Theta\left(\frac{n}{2}\right).$ Similarly at each level (total cost per level and not the cost per node in a level) the cost would be $\Theta\left(\frac{n}{2}\right)$ and so for $\log n$ levels it would be $\Theta({n} \log n).$

PS: Even if we change $\min$ to $\max$ in the defintion of $g(x)$ we get the same answer.

selected by
49 votes
49 votes

Do a post order traversal and store and return $\min \left( \text{g}(x \rightarrow left), \text{g}(x \rightarrow right ) \right )$ for all non leaf nodes and store $0$ for all leaf nodes and return 1. BST being balanced, with n leaf nodes we can have total 2n nodes and complexity of tree traversal is linear in number of nodes- $\Theta(n)$.

But this is just computing the time complexity of $g(x)$ for each node- not exactly what is asked in question.

Actually the procedure I gave is computing the COST of computing the value of $g(x)$ which would have been correct had the question been defined as 

$g(x) = \Large \min \left ( \substack{\text{number of leaf-nodes}\\ \text{in left-subtree of x}}\;,\; \substack{\text{number of leaf-nodes}\\\text{in right-subtree of x}}\right )$. 

The correct answer for this would be $\Theta(n \log n)$ as at each level, the cost is $\Theta(n)$ and we have $\log n$ levels since the tree is balanced.  

Correct Answer: $B$

edited by
24 votes
24 votes

1.if we use simple divide and conquer technique(without using extra space)

we first need to count no. of leaf in left subtree,then no. of leaf in right subtree+compare them to find minimum.

T(n)=2T(n/2)+1----->O(n)

but we need to compute this for every node.

so, cost at 0 th level=O(n)

cost at 1st level=n/2+n/2=O(n)

cost at 2nd level=n/4+n/4+n/4+n/4=O(n)\

we have total of logn levels (because tree is balanced) and cost at every level is O(n).

Hence total cost is=n*logn=O(nlogn)

2.if we use extra memory to store no of leaf at left subtree and at right subtree for every node

we don't need to go to last level for every node.

1.compute for every leaf node.

2.then use those values to compute at all nodes at (h-1) level till root.

so, time complexity of this method is equal to O(n),since we are calculating value for each node and doing only one comparison. 

space complexity is also O(n),since we are using extra memory for every node.

since question is asking about worst case time complexity,so we have O(nlogn) .

17 votes
17 votes

Let us assume a balanced binary tree containing n leaf nodes. We have to compute g(x) corresponding to every node x and the cost of computing g(x) is 

min(number of leaf-nodes in left-subtree of x,number of leaf-nodes in right-subtree of x).

we start from root and compute g(x) corresponding to every node.g(root) = min(n/2 , n/2) = Θ(n/2) =Θ(n).

Cost at level 1 :Θ(n).

Cost corresponding to second level :

g(left_node)= min(n/4,n/4)=n/4

g(right_node)=min(n/4,n/4)=n/4

Total cost at level 2 :Θ(n/4 + n/4) =Θ(n/2)=Θ(n)

Similarly total cost at level 3 : Θ(n/8 + n/8 +n/8 + n/8)=Θ(n/2)=Θ(n)

...There are totally log n levels since it is a balanced binary search tree and cost at every level is Θ(n).

There fore time complexity  of the program is Θ(n) . log n =Θ(n logn).

edited by
Answer:

Related questions

27 votes
27 votes
6 answers
1
Kathleen asked Sep 18, 2014
22,413 views
The following numbers are inserted into an empty binary search tree in the given order: $10, 1, 3, 5, 15, 12, 16$. What is the height of the binary search tree (the heigh...
62 votes
62 votes
4 answers
3
55 votes
55 votes
8 answers
4