GATE CSE
First time here? Checkout the FAQ!
x
+1 vote
278 views

I was reading some of the notes (made easy and ACE)  and noticed that some teacher have taught that time complexity for Binary Knapsack O(2^(n/2)). which can not be reduced further. but What I have seen here that in worst case by using memoization we can reduce the time complexity upto O(n.W) where n is number of Object and W is capacity of knapsack.

What I am thinking that, Is it really Binary knapsack is NPC, Like Travelling Salesman problem because TSP tales O(n^2*2^n) times to calculate the tour by using dynamic method, which is efficient than o(n^n) of TSP brutforce techniques? Put some light, Am I missing something. Should I stop seeing those notes which people have posted over the internet. 

asked in Algorithms by Veteran (34k points)   | 278 views

1 Answer

+2 votes
Best answer

See AFAIK in DP we consider only the distinct function calls .So Using DP the complexity of Binary knapsack is O(nW).

But for the larger value of W the the complexity of Binary knapsack is O(2n). Because in 0/1 knapsack has very less repetition

So for the larger value W ,0/1 knapsack will generate n level complete binary tree So it will have  2n function calls and the time complexity

becomes O(2n). So it one of NP complete problem.

answered by Veteran (37.3k points)  
selected by
@ManojK Can you explain more, What do you mean by larger value? and Why that O(nW) did not work in the larger value?

 for n=5, W=100000  Here w has larger value.

Here n is polynomial in length but length of  w not polynomial it  can anything.

When comparing this with the  brute force algo take O(2n), but depending on W, either the dynamic programming algorithm is more efficient or the brute force algorithm could be more efficient. (For example, for n=5, W=100000, brute force is preferable, but for n=30 and W=1000, the dynamic programming solution is preferable.)

@manojK sir, abhi samjha cheekylaugh

Related questions

0 votes
1 answer
1
asked in Algorithms by firki lama Junior (927 points)   | 69 views
+1 vote
0 answers
2
+1 vote
2 answers
3


Top Users Aug 2017
  1. Bikram

    4902 Points

  2. ABKUNDAN

    4704 Points

  3. akash.dinkar12

    3480 Points

  4. rahul sharma 5

    3158 Points

  5. manu00x

    3012 Points

  6. makhdoom ghaya

    2480 Points

  7. just_bhavana

    2388 Points

  8. stblue

    2138 Points

  9. Tesla!

    2060 Points

  10. joshi_nitish

    1758 Points


25,014 questions
32,140 answers
74,824 comments
30,185 users