The Gateway to Computer Science Excellence
First time here? Checkout the FAQ!
x
+13 votes
2.2k views

What is the converse of the following assertion?

  • I stay only if you go
  1. I stay if you go
  2. If I stay then you go
  3. If you do not go then I do not stay
  4. If I do not stay then you go
asked in Mathematical Logic by Veteran (59.7k points)
edited by | 2.2k views
+3

P  = "I stay" , Q = "you go"
question is P--->Q then option A is
i stay(P) <---- you go(Q)  , which means Q implies P

also Q---->P 

+2

I stay only if you go

    P: I stay

   Q: You go

It is given in the form of P if Q which is equivalent to (P→ Q), we can write that statement in this way,

If I stay then you go.

Along with that, we know that converse of (P→Q) is (Q→P)

we can write that converse in the English language is If you go then I stay and we can write this (Q→P) form to Q if P form.

which means If you go then I stay is equivalent to I stay if you go.

So the answer is option A

3 Answers

+21 votes
Best answer

"I stay only if you go" is equivalent to "If I stay then you go."

 $\because A \text{ only if } B  \equiv  (A \to B) $

$A=$ "I stay" and $B=$ "You go"

Converse $( A\to B)  =  B\to A$

"If you go then I stay"

Answer is  (A).

answered by Active (2.6k points)
edited by
0
Shouldn't it be B<->A because of "only if" statement. It is same as "if and only if".
+1

I think answer is B. 

I stay only if you go 

A = You go

B= I stay

So, given is A->B

Converse is B->A

So, ans is 

If I stay, then you go.

So, ans is B. 

Please explain me if I am wrong.

+1

I stay only if you go  is equivalent to if I stay then you go. check again

+4
Now I understood the meaning of "only if".... I thought A only if B means B->A.

But, A only if means A->B,

So ans is A.

Thanks for the explanation Anirudh...
+4

A only if B $\equiv$ A $\rightarrow$ B

Given : A $\rightarrow$ B  . We have to find all which given below for A $\rightarrow$ B ?

Direct = A $\rightarrow$ B

Converse = B $\rightarrow$ A

Inverse =  ~A $\rightarrow$ ~B

COntrapositive = ~B $\rightarrow$ ~A

0 votes
option a.  converse is B->A can also be written as "A if B" thats u ans (a)
answered by Junior (791 points)
0 votes

I stay only if you go is equivalents to   If I stay then you go.

  A only if B  => A->B

A= "I stay" and B= "You go"
i.e.Conditional: A ---.>B 
     Converse:   B----->A

" If you go then I stay "

Answer is  (A) A if B is equivalence to B -------->A
         "I stay if you go" is also equivalent to "If you go then I stay"

i.e.Conditional: P ---.>Q 
     Converse:  Q----->P 

answered by Boss (20.3k points)
edited by
Answer:

Related questions



Quick search syntax
tags tag:apple
author user:martin
title title:apple
content content:apple
exclude -tag:apple
force match +apple
views views:100
score score:10
answers answers:2
is accepted isaccepted:true
is closed isclosed:true

44,298 questions
49,785 answers
164,378 comments
65,857 users