GATE1994-18

Question

State whether the following statements are True or False with reasons for your answer

• A. A subroutine cannot always be used to replace a macro in an assembly language program.

• B. A symbol declared as ‘external’ in an assembly language program is assigned an address outside the program by the assembler itself.

Comments

can someone explain in detail ????

---

For part (B) refer ->

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/External_variable

If the program is in several source files, and a variable is defined in file1 and used in file2 and file3, then extern declarations are needed in file2 and file3 to connect the occurrences of the variable. The usual practice is to collect extern declarations of variables and functions in a separate file, historically called a header, that is included by #include at the front of each source file. The suffix .h is conventional for header names.

---

Chhotu 

why a is true?Any ref?

---

a)"The macros can take function like arguments, the arguments are not checked for data type"

Macros are preprocessor directive

But subroutine call is like function call, which can call nested function call.

So, subroutine call and macros are works for different objective

https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/interesting-facts-preprocessors-c/

b)The extern keyword means "declare without defining".

So, "program is assigned an address outside the program"- this is a wrong statement

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/External_variable

Answer 1

1. This is true. We can not replace macro entirely using subroutine. Ex -> Macro constant used for renaming.
    
2. This is false. This is job of Linker.

Comments

Can we Say like this, Macros are evaluated at compile time where as subroutine at run time.

Plz correct me if i am wrong.

---

Can anyone please give the reason for 1st statement ??

---

Can some one tell code where macro is used but subroutine  not possible

---

Example to support 1st clause

#define construct cannot be replaced by subroutine.

---

@Ayush

by tp what do u mean?

I cannot understand

Answer 2

B is false, as extern will not allocate memory. the memory will be allocated when that variable will be initialized or declared.

Comments

extern int i ... wat is the meaning of it ??

---

it mean memory is already allocated to this i outside of the function by linker not by assembler itself