Dark Mode

552 views

0 votes

10 rooms, numbered 1 to 10, need to be rewired, but there are constraints on the order in

which this can get done.

Rooms 5 and 8 must be rewired before starting on 6

Room 1 must be rewired rewired before starting on 7 and 9

Rooms 4 and 5 must be rewired before starting on 2

Rooms 8 and 10 must be rewired before starting on 5

Room 3 must be rewired rewired before starting on 1 and 4

Rooms 9 and 7 must be rewired before starting on 10

Rooms 9 and 10 must be rewired before starting on 8

Rewiring a room takes one full day. In a day, any number of rooms can be rewired simultaneously

provided the constraints above are met. What is the minimum number of days required to complete the

rewiring?

a) 10

b) 9

c) 8

d) 7

In the solution they have drawn a DAG from this and then finded the longest paths.

"Longest paths are 3-1-9-10-8-5-2, 3-1-7-10-8-5-6, 3-1-9-10-8-5-6 and 3-1-7-10-8-5-2 each of length 7." <--quoted from answer

How is it done?How is it connected to DAG?

which this can get done.

Rooms 5 and 8 must be rewired before starting on 6

Room 1 must be rewired rewired before starting on 7 and 9

Rooms 4 and 5 must be rewired before starting on 2

Rooms 8 and 10 must be rewired before starting on 5

Room 3 must be rewired rewired before starting on 1 and 4

Rooms 9 and 7 must be rewired before starting on 10

Rooms 9 and 10 must be rewired before starting on 8

Rewiring a room takes one full day. In a day, any number of rooms can be rewired simultaneously

provided the constraints above are met. What is the minimum number of days required to complete the

rewiring?

a) 10

b) 9

c) 8

d) 7

In the solution they have drawn a DAG from this and then finded the longest paths.

"Longest paths are 3-1-9-10-8-5-2, 3-1-7-10-8-5-6, 3-1-9-10-8-5-6 and 3-1-7-10-8-5-2 each of length 7." <--quoted from answer

How is it done?How is it connected to DAG?

1 vote

Best answer

I have done it by topological sorting method..

I am going to explain it by table because drawing diagram might make it dirty. But I will suggest you to draw it on your own following the steps mentioned. Then it will be very easy for you to understand. Refer the table for verification purpose.

1. Create 10 nodes.

2. Draw a directed edge b/w the node u->v if v is dependent on u. For eg: " Rooms 8 and 10 must be rewired before starting on 5 " Here we have to draw an edge directing from 8 and another directed edge from 10 to node 5.

3. After making all the edges note down the in-degree of each node i.e. no. of edges directing to a node.

I got :

in_deg(1) | 1 (directed from 3) |

in_deg(2) | 2 (directed from 4 and 5) |

in_deg(3) | 0 |

in_deg(4) | 1 (directed from 3) |

in_deg(5) | 2 (directed from 8 and 10) |

in_deg(6) | 2 (directed from 5 and 8) |

in_deg(7) | 1 (directed from 1) |

in_deg(8) | 2 (directed from 9 and 10) |

in_deg(9) | 1 (directed from 1) |

in_deg(10) | 2 (directed from 7 and 9) |

4. Now you can see that node 3 is the only independent node. It does not depend on any other node (indeg(3) =0). This means that before rewiring room no. 3 no other room needs to be rewired.

So start with 3 and cancel all the edges that originated from node 3. They are 1 and 4. So the indeg of 1 and 4 are reduced by 1.

What does this mean? Room no. 1 and 4 can be rewired only after 3 is done. [Point no. 5 in the list you gave ]

Now update the indeg of node 1 and 4.

in_deg(1) | 1-1=0 |

in_deg(2) | 2 |

in_deg(4) | 1-1=0 |

in_deg(5) | 2 |

in_deg(6) | 2 |

in_deg(7) | 1 |

in_deg(8) | 2 |

in_deg(9) | 1 |

in_deg(10) | 2 |

Now since in degree of 1 and 4 are 0 it means they are now independent of any other node. Both can be processed simultaneously because it is given that :

In a day, any number of rooms can be rewired simultaneously provided the constraints above are met.

So, till now 3,(1,4) are rewired.

5. Now update the table again and change the in degrees of those that that were dependent on 1 i.e. 9 and 7 and on 4 i.e. 2.

in_deg(2) | 2-1=1 |

in_deg(5) | 2 |

in_deg(6) | 2 |

in_deg(7) | 1-1=0 |

in_deg(8) | 2 |

in_deg(9) | 1-1=0 |

in_deg(10) | 2 |

So in deg of 9,7 are 0 now. They can be processed simultaneously.

So, till now 3,(1,4),(7,9) are rewired.

6. Again update the table by decreasing the in degrees of those nodes that were dependent on 2,7,9.

10 is dependent on 7. 8 and 10 are dependent on 9.

Hence in deg of 10 will be reduced by 2.

in_deg(2) | 1 |

in_deg(5) | 2 |

in_deg(6) | 2 |

in_deg(8) | 2-1=1 |

in_deg(10) | 2-2=0 |

So now in deg of 10 is 0 and no other node has in degree=0. Hence 10 is the only independent node at this stage.

So, till now 3,(1,4),(7,9),10 are rewired.

After rewiring room 10 we can move to room 5 and 8.

Decrease their in degree by 1.

7. Update the table:

in_deg(2) | 1 |

in_deg(5) | 2-1=1 |

in_deg(6) | 2 |

in_deg(8) | 1-1=0 |

Only node 8 has in degree 0. So process it and reduce the in degree of nodes dependent on 8 i.e. 6 and 5.

So, till now 3,(1,4),(7,9),10,8 are rewired.

8. Update the table :

in_deg(2) | 0 |

in_deg(5) | 1-1=0 |

in_deg(6) | 2-1=1 |

Now only in degree of 5 is 0. 2 and 6 are dependent on 5. Reduce in degree of 2 and 6 by 1.

So, till now 3,(1,4),(7,9),10,8,5 are rewired.

9. Update the table :

in_deg(2) | 1-1=0 |

in_deg(6) | 1-1=0 |

Now 2 and 6 can also be processed.

So, till now 3,(1,4),(7,9),10,8,5,(2,6) are rewired.

If you notice the order, 7 days are needed to complete rewiring.

3 on 1st day. (1 and 4) on 2nd day. (7 and 9) on 3rd day and so on...

Longest paths are 3-1-9-10-8-5-2, 3-1-7-10-8-5-6, 3-1-9-10-8-5-6 and 3-1-7-10-8-5-2 each of length 7.

Satisfied :)

End :P

edited
Aug 27, 2018
by MiNiPanda

haha :P I don't think so many nodes will be given during exam for finding topological order..even if there are many nodes, their in degrees shouldn't be too close to each other :p

Here after visiting one node the in degrees of so many other nodes are getting affected opening ways for so many orders!! -_-

Here after visiting one node the in degrees of so many other nodes are getting affected opening ways for so many orders!! -_-

0