473 views
6 6 votes

Let $H(x)$ : " $x$ is a happy person", where the universe is the set of all people. Which of the following correctly expresses "There exists exactly one happy person"?

  1. $\exists x(H(x) \wedge \forall y(H(y) \rightarrow x=y))$
  2. $\exists x \exists y(H(x) \wedge H(y) \wedge x \neq y)$
  3. $\forall x \forall y(H(x) \wedge H(y) \rightarrow x=y)$
  4. $ \exists x H(x) \wedge \exists y H(y) \wedge x \neq y$

3 Answers

1 1 vote

Option A: ∃x(H(x)∧∀y(H(y)→x=y)

Could be rewritten as : - ∃x∀y(H(x)∧H(y)→x=y)

It forces us to take a single x from the domain and check for all y and if the condition is True we have exactly one person in the domain who is happy, hence True.

For two happy person or no happy person the condition would be False.

Another way to quickly get the intuition behind this option would be:-

P : ∃x(H(x)) tells us about atleast one happy person in the domain.

Q: ∀y(H(y)→x=y) tells us about atmost one happy person in the domain.

P∧Q = atleast one happy AND atmost one happy = exactly one happy person.

 

Option B: ∃x∃y(H(x)∧H(y)∧x!=y)

Even if we get a pair satisfying this condition it’s not guaranteed to be a True for exactly one person, hence False.

 

Option C: ∀x∀y(H(x)∧H(y)→x=y)

This option will be true even if we have no happy person in the domain, hence False.

 

Option D: ∃xH(x)∧∃yH(y)∧x!=y

Not even a preposition as it contains free variables (x and y) which are free to take any values from the domain, hence we can’t satisfy the condition. 

 

• edited by
0 0 votes



Exactly one happy person = atleast one happy and atmost one happy 

Option A:  ∃x(H(x)∧∀y(H(y)→x=y))  
The blue coloured part says there exist some person x who is happy (This is atleast one happy) 
The Red Coloured part is not independent it goes together with atleast part so its read like there exist some person x who is happy and for all person y if y is also happy then x and y must be same 
So this is true 

Option B: It says there exist some person x and some person y who are happy and they are different so it means it says there exist atleast two happy person 

Option C: Looks correct but if we closely observe and assume there are no happy person in the set then also it is true, so this one is atmost one happy 

Option D: It is not a proposition it has free variable x and y 
 

Answer:
Position:
Show:

Related questions

3 3 votes
1 1 answer
259
259 views
GO Classes asked Apr 1
259 views
Let $H(x)$ : " $x$ is a happy person", where the universe is the set of all people. Which of the following correctly expresses "There exists at least one happy person"?$\...
8 8 votes
2 2 answers
651
651 views
GO Classes asked Apr 1
651 views
Consider the model (men, women, parent_of), and an interpretation in this model:$M$ domain of men$W$ domain of women$P(x, y) \quad y$ is a parent of $x$You may assume tha...
7 7 votes
2 2 answers
453
453 views
GO Classes asked Apr 1
453 views
Consider the model (men, women, parent_of), and an interpretation in this model:$M$ domain of men$W$ domain of women$P(x, y) \quad y$ is a parent of $x$You may assume tha...
5 5 votes
2 2 answers
301
301 views
GO Classes asked Apr 1
301 views
Consider the following two logical equivalences that express 'logical laws':- $\neg \exists x \in D f \equiv \forall x \in D \neg f$- $\neg(f \rightarrow g) \equiv \neg g...