1,267 views
3 votes
3 votes
Why are the duals of two equivalent compound propositions also equivalent, where these compound propositions contain only the operators $\wedge, \vee, \sim ?$

2 Answers

0 votes
0 votes

Suppose, P$_{1}$ & P$_{2}$ are two equivalent compound proposition. 

P$_{1}$ $\equiv$ P$_{2}$

then complement of these compound proposition is also equivalent. 

$\neg$P$_{1}$ $\equiv\neg$P$_{2}$

for e.g. : Suppose we have a function $f_{(a,b)}$.we make Truth Table of $f_{(a,b)}$ , 

a b P$_{1}$ P$_{2}$ $\neg$P$_{1}$ $\neg$P$_{2}$
F F F F T T
F T F F T T
T F T T F F
T T F F T T

from the above truth table we can prove that if P$_{1} \equiv$  P$_{2}$ then $\neg$P$_{1} \equiv \neg$P$_{2}$.

Complement of a function ($f_{c}$): complement of all literal, $\wedge$ changes to $\vee$, $\vee$ changes to $\wedge$, T to F, F to T. 

Dual of a function ($f^{*}$): $\wedge$ changes to $\vee$, $\vee$ changes to $\wedge$, T to F, F to T. 

Now, from the above definitions we can say that if $f$ is a function then complement of a function $f_{c}$ is equivalent to its dual $f^{*}$ by complementing of every literal of $f_{c}$ that means $f_{c} \equiv f^{*}$.

Hence, from $\neg$P$_{1}$ $\equiv\neg$P$_{2}$ we can conclude P$^{*}_{1} \equiv$ P$^{*}_{2}$.

–1 votes
–1 votes
The dual of a proposition is formed by replacing each occurrence of the logical operator "and" with "or", each occurrence of "or" with "and", and negating all propositions. If two compound propositions are equivalent, then their truth values will be the same for all possible combinations of truth values for their individual propositions. Because the dual of a proposition is formed by changing the logical operators and negating certain propositions, the truth values of the dual proposition will also be the same for all possible combinations of truth values for its individual propositions. Therefore, the duals of two equivalent compound propositions will also be equivalent.

Related questions

2 votes
2 votes
3 answers
2
0 votes
0 votes
2 answers
3
1 votes
1 votes
2 answers
4